Home ‣ Restaurants

Pizza Master Anthony Falco Brings Pizzeria the Pantheon Bar to Williamsburg

Line up now.
Written By: author avatar DiningOut Staff
author avatar DiningOut Staff
We went, we ate, we enjoyed what this great city has to offer.
Pizza master Anthony Falco opens a new shop in Williamsburg. | Photo courtesy of Pizzeria the Pantheon Bar pizza
Pizza master Anthony Falco opens a new shop in Williamsburg. | Photo courtesy of Pizzeria the Pantheon Bar

Brooklyn has a new pizza destination, and this one comes with a pedigree. Anthony Falco, the pizza master who helped turn Roberta’s into a global pizza destination, finally has his own restaurant. On Friday, November 20, Pizzeria the Pantheon Bar officially opens at 276 Grand St. in Williamsburg.

The pizzaiolo started making dough at the Bushwick landmark when it opened in 2008, and for the last decade he has consulted for pizzerias worldwide. Now he and his business partner, fellow Roberta’s alum Mateo Vivas, will run the new shop together.

But what’s in the name Pizzeria the Pantheon Bar? Turns out it pulls from two sources: Alejandro Jodorowsky’s 1973 film The Holy Mountain, which features a place called the Pantheon Bar, and the Pantheon in Rome where Queen Margherita is buried. Yes, that famous Margherita to whom we can credit with inspiring the classic tomato, fresh mozzarella, and basil pizza of the same name.

Chef Anthony Falco has brought his dough slinging skills all around the world. | Photo courtesy of Anthony Flaco pizzeria the pantheon bar
Chef Anthony Falco has brought his dough slinging skills all around the world. | Photo courtesy of Anthony Flaco

Expect the pizzas to land in the $20 price range, which the owners told Eater NY that they deliberately chose to keep the restaurant more accessible. Expect unique-sounding pies such as one made with sour cream and onion flavors to channel that famous potato chip. There’s also less-involved creations like the Crostino, a simple ham and cheese pizza.

To make each pizza, the kitchen relies on a 10-year-old sourdough starter that Falco carried around the world. Today said starter rests in a temperature-controlled room in the basement prep area, where dough is made with flour from the Pacific Northwest. On top off each pie you’ll find fresh mozzarella and Italian olive oil shipped directly to the shop by Falco’s cousin.

More details on Pizzeria the Pantheon Bar coming soon, including hours and menu items. Until then, dream of a new pizza shop in Brooklyn that’s sure to be a hit. And, in true NYC fashion, include a line out the door.


author avatar
DiningOut Staff
We went, we ate, we enjoyed what this great city has to offer.
dining-out-logo-white.svg
Search
COPYRIGHT © 2026, DININGOUT. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

Join the Gourmet Gold List