Home ‣ Restaurants

Readers Weigh In: The Best Places in Denver to Take Visitors

Written By: author avatar DiningOut Staff
author avatar DiningOut Staff
We went, we ate, we enjoyed what this great city has to offer.
For over 100 years this restaurant has stood in the same spot. | Photo courtesy of Buckhorn Exchange
For over 100 years this restaurant has stood in the same spot. | Photo courtesy of Buckhorn Exchange

Ask Denver residents where they’d take someone visiting the city for the first time, and you’ll get plenty of opinions. Some will point to a historic steakhouse, others will argue for a plate of green chile or a classic local burger. The recommendations reveal something important about the city’s dining scene: Denver’s culinary identity stretches well beyond one signature dish or style of restaurant.

The front of Domo feels like you're entering a Japanese cottage. | Photo by Linnea Covington
The front of Domo feels like you’re entering a Japanese cottage. | Photo by Linnea Covington

In a recent Facebook discussion on DiningOut’s page, readers shared their picks for the one restaurant they’d recommend to a first-time visitor. The conversation generated 159 comments and identified 18 unique restaurants. One longtime institution claimed the top spot, but the list also highlights neighborhood favorites, family-owned restaurants, and destinations with experiences visitors won’t find anywhere else.

Here are the restaurants Denver locals think deserve a place on every visitor’s dining itinerary. What did we miss? 

Buckhorn Exchange: A Taste of Denver’s Wild West

Dine among the taxidermy. | Photo courtesy of Buckhorn Exchange
Dine among the taxidermy. | Photo courtesy of Buckhorn Exchange

When Denver residents recommend one restaurant above all others, Buckhorn Exchange leads the conversation. With 12 mentions, the historic steakhouse topped the reader poll, and it’s easy to understand why.

Founded in 1893 by Henry H. “Shorty Scout” Zietz, Buckhorn Exchange holds the distinction of Denver’s oldest restaurant. The restaurant still occupies the original building at 1000 Osage St., where taxidermy animals, Western memorabilia, and historic photographs give the dining rooms the atmosphere of an Old West saloon.

The menu carries that frontier theme to the table. Alongside steaks, diners can order elk, bison, rattlesnake and alligator. The restaurant also serves a longtime favorite: Navy Bean and Ham Soup, which follows Zietz’s original recipe. Rocky Mountain oysters remain a signature appetizer, though it’s more of a tourist favorite than local go to. 

The bean and ham soup has been a menu staple for decades. | Photo courtesy of Buckhorn Exchange
The bean and ham soup has been a menu staple for decades. | Photo courtesy of Buckhorn Exchange

Gaetano’s: North Denver’s Italian-American History

Gaetano’s earned six mentions, making it the second-most-recommended restaurant in the discussion. The Highland neighborhood spot has deep roots in north Denver and a history that connects Italian-American food with the city’s colorful past.

The Smaldone family opened the restaurant, and their association with Denver’s underworld helped establish a reputation as one of the city’s most storied dining destinations. Today, Gaetano’s pairs that vintage atmosphere with classic Italian-American cooking and a full bar.

Casa Bonita: The Pink Landmark Everyone Knows

Casa Bonita is located in a complex in Lakewood. | Photo courtesy of Casa Bonita
Casa Bonita is located in a complex in Lakewood. | Photo courtesy of Casa Bonita

A Denver visitor’s itinerary wouldn’t feel complete without considering Casa Bonita. The Lakewood landmark earned five mentions, tying it with the diner Sam’s No. 3.

It’s easy to see why since Casa Bonita goes beyond the traditional restaurant experience. The iconic pink exterior opens into a sprawling indoor destination with themed streets, waterfalls, cliff divers, roaming entertainment, and dining areas. Yes, it’s just what the show South Park depicted. 

Casa Bonita's Green Enchiladas. | Photo by Casa Bonita
Casa Bonita’s Green Enchiladas. | Photo by Casa Bonita

Beyond the kitsch, the experience has entertained generations of Colorado families. When Matt Stone and Trey Parker, creators of South Park, took ownership, they brought in chef Dana Rodriguez to refresh the food while preserving the restaurant’s familiar character. 

The updated model ditched the cafeteria vibe and now features table service and a menu full of  enchiladas, carnitas, mole, adobo chicken, and calabacitas. Of course, the famous sopapillas, served with honey, remain part of the experience and you can raise a flag for more.

Sam’s No. 3: A Denver Diner With a Little of Everything

The menu at Sam's No. 3 reads like a book, and this Reuben is just one of the items. | Photo by Ruth Tobias
The menu at Sam’s No. 3 reads like a book, and this Reuben is just one of the items. | Photo by Ruth Tobias

Sam’s No. 3 also received five mentions. The downtown diner has served Denver diners in various forms since 1927, and its enormous menu makes it an easy recommendation for groups with different appetites.

The menu spans traditional diner cuisine including breakfast favorites, Mexican-American fare, and Colorado comfort food. Order a Coney Dog, Gyro Wrap, Buffalo Cheeseburger, or the restaurant’s signature green chili, which can accompany almost anything. 

Pete’s Kitchen: Colfax Comfort Food

A classic diner-style cheeseburger at Pete's Kitchen. | Photo by Max Sutton-Vermeulen
A classic diner-style cheeseburger at Pete’s Kitchen. | Photo by Max Sutton-Vermeulen

A few blocks of East Colfax Avenue tell plenty of Denver stories, and Pete’s Kitchen has occupied an important place in that history. That’s probably why the diner earned four mentions in the reader poll.

Though the restaurant has existed in the spot in some capacity since 1936, it was in 1988 when restaurateur Pete Contos helped build the spot into a Denver institution. Though the 24-hour service changed during the pandemic, Pete’s Kitchen is still known for having generous portions, Greek-American specialties, and breakfast all day. Though not fancy or mind blowing in any way, the classic diner feel makes it a place locals want to share with out-of-town friends and family. 

Domo: Japanese Country Cooking in Denver

The front room at Domo. | Photo by Linnea Covington
The front room at Domo. | Photo by Linnea Covington

Domo received three mentions, earning recognition for its distinctive approach to Japanese food and transportive atmosphere. Located at 1365 Osage St., the restaurant brings diners into old school Japan with a rustic setting, traditional decor, wood interiors, and a Japanese garden.

Unlike most Denver Japanese restaurants, Domo specializes in regional country cooking, featuring curries, pickled vegetables, and soups. There’s no place like it in Colorado. 

More Local Favorites Worth the Trip

The bar is just as nice as the dining area. | Photo by Joni Schrantz
The bar at Rioja in Downtown Denver. | Photo by Joni Schrantz

Several other restaurants earned noteworthy mentions too. For example, La Loma, which has long built a reputation around Mexican comfort food, particularly the green chili. Steakhouse 10, located in Englewood, also earned mentions, as did long time favorites Rioja, Bastien’s, and the Cherry Cricket, which now has four locations.

Tocabe: An American Indian Eatery, deserves particular attention from visitors interested in Colorado’s Indigenous food traditions. The Native-owned restaurant, founded by Osage Nation member Ben Jacobs, showcases indigenous ingredients and cooking through dishes such as Bison Ribs, Fry Bread Tacos, Green Chile Stew, and bowls featuring ingredients sourced from Native producers.

Overall, the results make one thing clear: Denver locals don’t agree on just one restaurant that defines the city. Instead, they recommend a mix of historic institutions, neighborhood diners, independent restaurants, and destinations that celebrate different culinary traditions. But no matter the reason you, the main point is spending time with the person your visiting with at one of their favorite spots. 

author avatar
DiningOut Staff
We went, we ate, we enjoyed what this great city has to offer.
dining-out-logo-white.svg
Search
COPYRIGHT © 2026, DININGOUT. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

Join the Gourmet Gold List